Sunday, April 14, 2024

Disadvantages Of Gamma Knife Surgery

How Does Each Compare

Pros and Cons of Gamma Knife

Both Gamma Knife radiosurgery and CyberKnife have their advantages and drawbacks, depending on the application. In instances when pain such as trigeminal neuralgia is involved, resolution of symptoms can be very slow to come about, as the nerve is not immediately affected. This is in stark contrast to procedures such as microvascular decompression, where the patient often experiences immediately noticeable relief from pain and symptoms.

On the other hand, both Gamma Knife radiosurgery and CyberKnife provide an alternative to traditional surgery and radiation therapies. Of course, the efficacy depends on the area being treated, the type of tumor or lesion being treated, and its advancement. To gain better insight into each procedure, different facets of Gamma Knife vs. CyberKnife have been outlined below.

Gamma Knife Perfexion Treatment Has Many Benefits

It is bloodless, virtually painless, no loss of hair and rapid return to pre-treatment activities. Gamma Knife therapy may be suggested as an adjunct to standard neurosurgical therapy or as the preferred course of treatment when further traditional therapy is not recommended.

Gamma Knife treatment may also replace brain surgery in some patients with brain tumors, vascular malformations and facial pain. An individual who would be at risk for complications from conventional surgery may be a candidate for Gamma Knife radiosurgery. Gamma Knife treatment can be used when prior surgery or radiation therapy has failed to control the disease process. It can also be used in conjunction with conventional surgery in previously inoperable cases, other forms of radiation therapy and chemotherapy.

The benefits of Gamma Knife Perfexion treatment differs from conventional radiation therapy of the brain because it is only directed to targeted areas and spares unnecessary treatment of adjacent, normal brain tissue. Only a one-day treatment is required rather than many treatments over several weeks, and the treatment often can be repeated if necessary.

Most patients typically return to pre-treatment activities within a few days. The only restrictions are the same the patient had prior to treatment.

2022 Thompson Cancer Survival Center1901 Clinch Avenue

What Are The Risks And Potential Complications Of Gamma Knife Surgery

Complications of gamma knife surgery are uncommon, but any procedure involves risks and potential complications that may become serious in some cases. Complications can develop during the procedure or recovery.

Risks and potential complications of gamma knife surgery include:

  • Adverse reaction or problems related to sedation, such as an allergic reaction and problems with breathing

  • Bleeding or other discharge at the pin sites

Also Check: How Long After Meniscus Surgery Can I Walk

How Is Gamma Knife Surgery Performed

Your gamma knife will be performed in a hospital. The entire process occurs during a single day and generally includes these steps:

  • You will dress in a patient gown and remove any jewelry, wigs, glasses or any other items that may interfere with the radiation treatment.

  • A treatment team member will start an intravenous line. You will receive fluids and a mild sedative or other medications during the procedure.

  • You will have four small injections of local anesthetic to numb the area in your scalp.

  • Your care team will attach a head frame to your head with pins at the site of the anesthetic injections. They will not need to shave your hair to do this. Some people report a feeling of pressure when they are fitted with a head frame, but it usually goes away within a few moments.

  • The treatment team will take brain imaging scans to precisely locate your tumor or target area. The scan might be a magnetic resonance imaging scan , a computed tomography scan , a cerebral angiogram, or a combination of these.

  • You will wait in a separate room while your care team determines the exact treatment plan and where to apply the radiation.

  • You will return to the gamma knife treatment room and lie on a sliding bed. Your care team will fit a treatment helmet, called a collimator helmet, over your head frame. The helmet has a special pattern of holes in it. The holes will direct radiation beams to pass through to the exact location in your brain needing treatment.

  • Will I feel pain?

    In The Months After Your Procedure

    Gamma knife has great success against small brain tumors

    Some patients treated using Gamma Knife radiosurgery to the head will experience swelling of the brain approximately six months following treatment. This Gamma Knife risk is managed using medication, and neurological problems following treatment are rare.

    You may also be undergoing additional treatments during this time. Though many patients benefit from a single session of Gamma Knife radiosurgery, some conditions will require multiple treatments, depending on the size, location and nature of the area being treated.

    Also Check: Calf Reduction Surgery Before And After

    What Happens Before The Gamma Knife Procedure

    Medical review

    • Your neurosurgeon gathers your medical history and perform a complete physical exam. You may undergo additional tests.
    • Tell your provider if you have any of the following: heart pacemaker, aneurysm clip, implanted medication pump, implanted nerve stimulator, metal implants, metal from trauma, cochlear implant, spine stabilization hardware, severe lung disease, esophageal reflux or are unable to lay flat on your back for 30 to 60 minute periods.
    • Tell your provider if you are sensitive to or are allergic to any medications, latex, tape, contrast dyes, iodine or general or local anesthetic agents.

    Eating, drinking, medication

    • Dont eat or drink anything after midnight the evening before your procedure .
    • Take your morning medications with sips of water the morning of your treatment. Bring all prescribed and over-the-counter medications, including inhalers, with you.

    Hair prep, clothing

    • Wash your scalp the night before your Gamma Knife procedure. Wear your hair loose. Dont use clips, pins or bands. Your head will not be shaved.
    • On the day of the procedure, wear slip-on shoes comfortable pants, slacks, skirt or shorts and a button-up or zip-front shirt with loose-fitting or short sleeves. Dont wear a shirt that must be put on/taken off over your head.


    • A family member or friend will need to bring you on the day of the procedure and drive you home after treatment. They don’t necessarily need to stay during the procedure itself.

    Cyberknife Vs Gamma Knife

    While there are many comparisons to the Gamma Knife, the CyberKnife System is the only dedicated stereotactic radiosurgery treatment technology that also can be used to deliver stereotactic body radiation therapy for treatments throughout the body.

    Both the CyberKnife System and Gamma Knife are used to deliver stereotactic radiosurgery treatments to address tumors, vascular lesions, and functional disorders, such as trigeminal neuralgia or AVM. The treatments are designed to treat inoperable or recurrent brain tumors, and can be used for patients who do not want to endure the risks of surgery. However, there are some crucial differences between Gamma Knife and CyberKnife.

    Also Check: Home Remedies For Nerve Pain After Surgery

    Benefits Of Gamma Knife

    When youre facing brain surgery, you want a treatment option with low risk and a high rate of success. Gamma Knife surgery is just such an option, providing an alternative to surgery and other less-effective radiation therapies. After thousands of studies, this noninvasive procedure is considered the gold standard treatment for trigeminal neuralgia, metastatic and benign brain tumors, acoustic neuroma, and arteriovenous malformations.

    Gamma Knife treatment is successful in 70 to 90 percent of all cases, providing the best outcomes of all available treatment options.

    Since its introduction to the U.S. in 1987, Gamma Knife surgery has become a safer, more accurate alternative for patients with brain tumors and vascular malformations who were once treated with open surgery. The Gamma Knife is designed specifically to treat brain disorders and it is sometimes the only option for those whose hard-to-reach tumors were once considered inoperable.

    Gamma Knife surgery offers the following benefits:

    Gkrs Procedures For Vascular Malformations

    CJW Doc Minute: What are the side effects of gamma knife surgery?

    Using local anesthesia with or without sedation, the patients head is fixed in a Leksell Coordinate Frame G . The patient is then sent to a radiographic suite to undergo stereotactic imaging studies, including magnetic resonance imaging , computed tomography , and digital subtraction angiography . These imaging studies are performed with fitting of an appropriate indicator on the frame, which imposes fiducials on images of the patient. The acquired image dataset is then sent to GammaPlan , a radiosurgical planning software program. In creating the radiosurgical plan, an appropriate prescription dose is aimed at the targets margin usually using a 5060% isodose gradient while a 7090% isodose gradient occasionally is used in patients with a relatively small target. A margin, the setting of which is usually recommended in linac-based radiosurgery, is not required.

    Recommended Reading: Commonwealth Oral And Facial Surgery

    Advantages And Disadvantages Of Gamma Knife Surgery

    Advantagesof GammaKnifeGammaKnife offers several advantages, including: Noninvasive and painless Outpatient procedure with no anesthesia Shorter treatment time than traditional radiation therapy Precise radiation delivery with reduced side effects Less damage to surrounding to tissue. The GammaKnife is not actually a knife at all. It is a stereotactic radiosurgical device that non-invasively treats malignant and benign brain tumors, vascular malformations and trigeminal neuralgia in a single patient visit. Patients are treated on an out-patient basis or may require an overnight hospital stay. TOP.. While both CyberKnife and GammaKnife precisely treat cancerous, noncancerous, and recurrent tumors, CyberKnife has distinct advantages. Because of the more advanced technology, CyberKnife can treat tumors in organs throughout the body that move with normal breathing by utilizing real-time X-ray images of the targeted location..

    High Dose of Evidence – Over 2,500 medical papers have been published on GammaKnifesurgery, and 800,000 patients have been treated worldwide. Other types of radiation treatment often claim to be as accurate and effective, but they don’t have the data and proven results of GammaKnife. GammaKnife Radiosurgery has many advantages compared with traditional surgery and other types of radiation treatment. Neurosurgeons and patients often prefer GammaKnife Radiosurgery because: Its an outpatient procedure that takes less than a day.

    Whats The Outlook After Undergoing The Gamma Knife Procedure

    The success of the Gamma Knife procedure depends on the size, location, type of lesion, your personal medical history, and other factors. Discuss your expectations and outlook with your neurosurgeon and your radiation oncologist before treatment.

    The goal of Gamma Knife surgery is for the radiation to stabilize, shrink or destroy the tumor or lesion. Depending on your condition, you may or may not need additional Gamma Knife treatment or traditional now-more-manageable surgery. You will have follow-up CT and/or MRI scans to check on treatment progress.

    It may take weeks, months, a year to see the full effects of treatment. For example, pain relief if you have trigeminal neuralgia can occur anytime between one day and six months, with most people improving within one month. Cancerous tumors typically become stable or get smaller over a period of weeks to months. Many noncancerous tumors stop growing immediately , but may not get smaller in size. Arteriovenous malformations may take two to three years to resolve after treatment.

    You May Like: Surgery To Make Feet Smaller

    Gamma Knife Treatment For Essential Tremor

    It is one of the common neurological motor disorders. The disease causes one part of the body to move uncontrollably. The Gamma Knife surgery uses a potent dose of precise radiation to destroy the target tissue and interrupt the signals the brain sends to the muscles, ordering them to move. The treatment procedure is one-day and does not require a hospital stay. Most patients report an improvement in their condition and a decrease in tremors three to six months after the procedure.

    Patients with essential tremors have several treatment options. Most often, they have prescribed medications known as beta blockers. Unfortunately, for many patients who have asthma, diabetes, and some heart diseases, using beta-blockers is impossible. Gamma knife surgery is an ideal alternative treatment method for patients who cannot take beta blockers and do not respond to medications.

    What Happens During The Procedure

    Radiotherapy Dosimetry Applications of PRESAGE

    Youll be placed in the proper position on a table. Then, a computer-controlled robot will move slowly around the table, targeting radiation where its needed. The software will adjust radiation for your breathing pattern and any movement of the tumor.

    This is a noninvasive, painless procedure. Each session will last anywhere from 30 to 90 minutes. Once its over, you should be able to get up and resume your normal activities right away.

    Also Check: Can Teens Get Prostate Cancer

    Don’t Miss: How Much Is Plastic Surgery For Nose

    Gamma Knife Surgery Risks: Procedure Facts

    The invention of Gamma Knife in 1967 was a game changer for patients with neurological conditions that were untreatable with conventional surgery. It also gave doctors a valuable tool to help those who lacked the health needed to withstand general anesthesia. Like all medical procedures, the remediation carries some likelihood of adverse effects but they should be viewed within the context of the potential for considerable benefit.

    The discussion below will provide an overview of the process, which will enable you to understand how Gamma Knife surgery risks pale when weighed against the treatments advantages.

    Microsurgery Vs Gamma Knife Radiosurgery For The Treatment Of Brainstem Cavernous Malformations: A Systematic Review And Meta

    • Department of Neurosurgery, Xijing Hospital, Fourth Military Medical University, Xi’an, China

    Background: Brainstem cavernous malformations are a subset of cerebral cavernous malformations with precarious locations and potentially devastating clinical courses. The effects and outcomes of treating BSCMs by microsurgery or gamma knife radiosurgery vary across studies.

    Methods: We searched the Medline, Web of Science, The Cochrane Library, PubMed, and China Biology Medicine disc databases for original articles published in peer-reviewed journals of cohort studies reporting on 20 or more patients of any age with BSCMs with at least 80% completeness of follow-up.

    Results: We included 43 cohorts involving 2,492 patients. Both microsurgery and GKRS demonstrated great efficacy in reducing the rehemorrhage rate after treatment for BSCMs. The incidence rates of composite outcomes were 19.8 and 15.7 after neurosurgery and radiosurgery, respectively. In addition, we found statistically significant differences in the median numbers of patients between neurosurgical and radiosurgical cohorts in terms of symptomatic intracranial hemorrhage and persistent focal neurological deficit .

    The reported effects of treating BSCMs by microsurgery or GKRS are favorable for reducing recurrent hemorrhage from BSCMs. Patients in the neurosurgery cohort had a lower incidence of symptomatic ICH, while patients in the radiosurgical cohort had a lower incidence of persistent FND.

    You May Like: The Clinic For Plastic Surgery

    Comparing Cyberknife To Gamma Knife

    Both CyberKnife and Gamma Knife are dedicated stereotactic radiosurgery treatment technologies, but Gamma Knife is limited to only treating cancer above the ear and in the cervical spine. However, CyberKnife is the only dedicated SRS and stereotactic body radiotherapy system capable of treating cancer throughout the entire body.

    Both CyberKnife and Gamma Knife are primary treatments for cancerous and non-cancerous tumors. They are also effective treatments for vascular lesions and functional disorders, such as Trigeminal Neuralgia and AVM. The commonality between the two treatments lies in the fact that both aim to eliminate tumors and to achieve an outcome similar to surgery. However, while both are highly targeted therapies, there are crucial differences between CyberKnife and Gamma Knife.

  • The principle difference between Gamma Knife and CyberKnife is that Gamma Knife requires a large metal frame be mounted onto the patients head with screws before and during treatment. CyberKnife is a non-invasive and pain-free treatment that allows patients to lie comfortably on a treatment couch while the system moves quickly around them.
  • CyberKnife patients require no general or local anesthesia during the procedure, unlike Gamma Knifes.
  • CyberKnife is a dedicated robotic system that can approach a tumor in the brain, head, neck, and spine from over 1,300 positions with pinpoint sub-millimeter accuracy. Gamma Knife is a gantry-designed system that is limited to 190 positions.
  • Conditions Gamma Knife Is Used To Treat

    Mayo Clinic Minute: How gamma knife surgery treats brain tumors

    Gamma Knife surgery risks are relatively minor, so neurosurgeons frequently use the intervention to treat several disorders. These include trigeminal neuralgia, a condition involving periods of extreme facial pain, as well as acoustic neuroma, a noncancerous mass that affects the hearing nerves. In addition, Gamma Knife is one of the top methods for remediating inoperable brain tumors and arteriovenous malformations.

    Don’t Miss: Cleft Palate Before And After Surgery

    In The Days After Your Procedure

    For the first few days following your treatment, you may feel more fatigued than usual. Your body will need a little time to recover, so be sure you get plenty of rest and give yourself a chance to heal. Some patients experience swelling or discomfort at the site of treatment, which will typically resolve within the first week.

    Even if you did not experience a headache or nausea immediately following your Gamma Knife procedure, you may start to feel discomfort after a short delay. Should this be the case, be sure you let your doctor know so she can prescribe you medications if necessary.

    Prostate Cancer: Surgery Vs Radiation Vs Cyberknife

    An analysis of more than a dozen studies indicate that prostate cancer patients do better with surgery vs. radiation treatment especially men with localized prostate cancer.

    Patients treated with radiation are twice as likely to die from prostate cancer,one a half times likely to die sooner than prostate cancer patients treated with surgery, exposure to radiation may end in secondary cancers such as bladder cancer and rectal cancer.

    Dr. David Samadi explores the details.

    When men are diagnosed with prostate cancer it can be extremely confusing at times picking the right treatment option as theres a lot of information out there.

    Dr David Samadi says that with any cancer, surgery should be the first line of treatment.

    With prostate cancer surgery patients get accurate staging i.e. how much cancer a patient has, has the cancer spread to surrounding tissues the PSA levels which has always got to be zero.

    He says that patients are led to believe that radiation is a viable first line of treatment if the cancer comes back, it is extremely difficult to perform surgery after radiation.

    Dr. Samadi also explain why it is extremely important to weigh in the experience of the surgeon as working with the right doctor would ensure a better and faster recovery.

    Dr. David Samadis patients have a continence percentage of 95% 97% regular sexual functionality in about 80% of prostate cancer patients.

    Some prostate cancer facts:

    Don’t Miss: Physical Therapy After Meniscus Surgery

    Latest news
    Related news