Wednesday, April 10, 2024

Knee Pain After Acl Surgery 2 Years

How To Know If Acl Injury Failed

How to Diagnose and Rehab a Knee Injury | Sports Injury Clinic

The best means to determine if an ACL reconstruction graft is torn is by either the patients history or by a good clinical exam. Unfortunately, MRI scans are not very effective for determining the function of an ACL graft. Usually, a patient will describe difficulty with twisting, turning, and pivoting and this usually indicates that an ACL reconstruction graft has failed, even if the MRI shows a stout ACL reconstruction graft present in the knee. In addition, the presence of an increased amount of anterior tibial translation on the Lachmans test, usually a grade 2 Lachmans test, as well as the presence of a pivot shift test of at least a grade 2, indicates that an ACL graft is nonfunctional and stretched out and probably not working sufficiently to prevent reinjury to the athlete. Other secondary signs of an ACL graft not working include bone bruises in the lateral compartment on an MRI scan . Less commonly, ACL stress x-rays or the use of a KT-1000 stress machine can also be used to objectively determine the increase in anterior tibial translation. It is felt that a 3 mm increase in anterior tibial translation compared to the contralateral knee is indicative of a nonfunctional ACL reconstruction graft.

Normal Short Term Problems

People usually recover really well after ACL surgery, but many report afew problems in the early stages. These are completely normal andusually nothing to worry about.

Common problems after ACL surgery include:

  • Swelling: Swelling can last up to 3 months after ACL surgery. This can be eased by using RICE therapy, a combination of appropriate rest, ice therapy, elevation and tubigrip compression bandage visit the RICE section to find out more.
  • Difficulty Kneeling: Kneeling often causes pain after surgery initially, but with gradual progression through use of a cushion, then carpet, then hard floor, this usually improves.
  • Bruising: Bruising often appears down to the heel and can last 4-6 weeks. It can make the lower leg very tender. Keeping the leg elevated can help with this.
  • Numbness: Numbness around the scars is common due to damage to the small nerves around the knee from the incisions. It usually settles down after a few months, but occasionally it can persist long term. Numbness does not usually cause any functional problems.
  • Knee Pain: Some pain after ACL surgery is common both at the knee itself and around the new graft area but it is usually quite tolerable. It is important to be taking regular, adequate pain relief as advised by your doctor to keep this under control so you can follow your rehab programme
  • Rehab Phase : Weeks 1

    The first 2 weeks of ACL surgery recovery concentrates on regaining full range of movement at the knee, particularly extension . Flexion the knee, tends to be easier to regain.

    You will work on a rehab programme with your physio which you need to do daily.

    • Be off crutches
    • Have regained nearly full range of movement at your knee

    Also Check: Cataract Surgery Post Op Instructions

    Acl And Knee Pain Treatment In Nyc

    The team at NYDNRehab has rehabilitated over 100 patients with torn ACLs over the past six years. All had ACL tear treatment without surgery using our meticulous approach and advanced modern technology. Our results closely reflect those of various research studies. Only 20 of our patients were unable to return to sports, and subsequently went for surgical ACL repair.

    At NYDNRehab, we go beyond treating symptoms of pain and dysfunction. Our advanced technologies and innovative treatment methods enable us to identify the underlying causes, collect baseline data, and develop rehabilitation protocols that restore neuromuscular and neurocognitive function. Our end goal is to eliminate pain and dysfunction, so our patients can enjoy the very best quality of life.

    Preoperative Laxity Of The Knee And Excessive Graft Laxity As A Cause Of Acl Surgery Failure


    Lets go back to 2001 and a well-documented summary of ACL complications that can be found in the abstract of a classic lecture presentation from the Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh. This lecture was delivered in 2001.

    From 2001: Many factors influence the overall success or failure of anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction, including the integrity of the secondary restraints , the collateral ligaments, the mid-third capsular ligaments, the meniscus, and the iliotibial band), the preoperative laxity of the knee, the status of the articular and meniscal cartilage. . .

    As we noted in the research above untreated associated ligaments insufficiencies, in other words, the other knee ligaments were too weak to support the new ACL, which caused the failure.

    Also Check: Prayer For Someone Having Surgery

    Acl Vs Mcl Tears And Surgery

    ACL tears and MCL tears are the two most common knee injuries in active adults. And while these two ligaments are involved in the majority of knee injuries, their function within the knee and corresponding treatment after injury arent as similar as you might think.

    Torn ACL

    The ACL stretches diagonally across the middle of the knee and helps with rotational stability, as well as controlling the back and forth motion of the knee. The MCL connects the femur to the tibia and helps stabilize and control the sideways movement of the knee.

    Together, the ACL and MCL are vital to knee stability and functionality. And while ACL tears and MCL tears can differ in severity and treatment, most tears will not heal on their own.

    Torn MCL

    Luckily, all but the most severe MCL tears are typically treatedwith physical therapy. MCL rehab and recovery can be a long road filled withmobility and strengthening exercises, but it doesnt usuallyrequire surgery.

    ACL tears, however, are a whole different story.

    Rehab Phase : Weeks 6

    Phase three on the ACL surgery recovery timeline is when the knee is mostvulnerable. The new graft is at its weakest 6-12 weeks after surgery soextra care should be taken during this period. You will be able startmore challenging strengthening and balance/proprioception exercises.

    Inthis phase can also ususally start the following activities:

    • Swimming: You can usually start swimming in this phase, but you need to start with front crawl. Breast stroke should not be done until you are at least 4 months post-op
    • Cycling: start by using a static bike, gradually building up the resistance
    • Running: start by jogging at up to 40% of your normal pace. You want to avoid changing direction initially so make sure you are running in a straight line on even ground. Your physio will guide you on how to progress from here

    Before starting any of these activities, talk to your physical therapist to check you are ready. Any side-to-side or pivoting activities must be avoided.

    Also Check: L4 L5 Bulging Disc Surgery Recovery

    Why Is My Knee Still Buckling After Acl Surgery

    The knee buckle is most likely to stop as soon as the ACL injury is healed. This condition is caused by knee arthritis. In addition to pain and stiffness, arthritis can cause knee buckle because the cartilage wears away and the joint surfaces wear away over time.

    After an ACL or pcl injury, knee stiffness is common, especially in the latter stages of recovery. Manipulation is required to gain range of motion. You should speak with an orthopedist online right away. It is never a good idea to disregard professional medical advice or to postpone seeking it out of fear of what you read on this site.

    Clinical Results At 3

    Why does my knee pop or crack after knee surgery?

    Demographics of the patients and clinical evaluation scores are listed in Table 1. At the time of ACL reconstruction, medial meniscus tears were found in 2 patients, lateral meniscus tears in 5 patients, and both medial and lateral meniscus tears in 1 patient. All the meniscus tears were treated with partial meniscectomy. All the patients had an uneventful recovery after ACL reconstruction. 3 years after surgery, physical examinations revealed a normal range of motion, a negative Lachman test, a negative pivot shift test, and a within 3 mm side-to-side anterior drawer test at 25° of knee flexion) in all patients. 7 patients had excellent Lysholm knee scores and had returned to the same pre-injury level of sports activity, or 1 level lower, according to the Tegner scale . 3 patients had a fair Lysholm knee score . There were wide variations in scores for KOOS items among the patients. 8 patients had occasional pain in their ACL-reconstructed knees after moderate recreational sports or moderate working activities.

    You May Like: Recovery For Carpal Tunnel Surgery

    Recovery From Acl Surgery

    After anterior cruciate ligament surgery, move your ankles up and down an average of 10 times every 10 minutes. Continue this exercise for two to three days to help blood circulation and to prevent blood clots from forming in your legs. If you develop acute pain in the back of your calf, tell your doctor. This could be an early sign of clots.

    Can Acl Surgery Fail

    ACL surgery can fail, even in the best of circumstances. It is generally felt that a well-done ACL reconstruction has about a 5% chance of failure due to trauma. The most common cause of an ACL graft failure is a technical error with malposition of the original ACL reconstruction tunnels. Other causes of ACL failure include missed or unrecognized concurrent diagnoses, such as meniscal root tears, meniscal ramp tears, posterolateral corner injuries or MCL tears, or the original graft choice.

    A large number of studies have indicated that the use of cadaver grafts in younger patients have a much higher risk of failure. Thus, most ACL high-volume surgeons would use a patients own tissue for their ACL reconstruction when they are younger. In addition, patients who have a lot of laxity, especially patients who have increased heel heights or knee hyperextension, have a much higher risk of having cadaver graft or ones own hamstrings graft stretch out, and these patients may be indicated for using a patellar tendon autograft. Failure of an ACL reconstruction needs a complete workup to ensure that the same problem is not repeated the second time around and to make sure that the patient has the best chance of success after a revision surgery.

    You May Like: How Long Does Wrist Surgery Take

    The Appeal And Enthusiasm For Acl Reconstruction Surgery Is This Misguideda Patient Will Say: What Other Choice Did I Have But To Get The Surgery

    Many times we will see a patient following anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. To these patients we ask a simple question:

    • Why did you have the surgery?

    Many times the patient will give an equally simple answer:

    • What other choice did I have?

    There are options to the ACL surgery and revision surgery as we will discuss below:

    How I Manage My Knee 3 Years Post Op

    Ligament tear, Knee injury, Cruciate ligament tear

    Here are some things I do to help manage my knee:

    • Use heat before training and apply when its feeling tight.
    • Take ibprofen .
    • Use my compex on my knee.
    • Foam rolling, especially on the quad and VMO.
    • Doing a few extra exercises for balance, glute activation, and landing before/during warmup.
    • Taking time to cool down after working out.
    • Wearing a compression sleeve if its bothered.

    You May Like: Dry Eyes After Lens Replacement Surgery

    The Road To Preventing Acl Revision Surgery Ligament Strengthening

    In this video Ross Hauser, MD explains a simple injection technique Prolotherapy for strengthening the ACL

    Video transcript summary:

    • For Grade 1 and Grade 2 tear of ACL, Prolotherapy injections can be an effective non-surgical option
    • If somebody has a complete anterior cruciate ligament tear they should get surgery to repair it but then after surgery Prolotherapy should be considered because Prolotherapy will stimulate the healing and strengthening of the attachments of the transplanted ACL. There are two attachments of the anterior cruciate ligament at the tibial tubercle and at the lateral femoral condyle. Prolotherapy strengthens these attachment points.
    • Prolotherapy is very effective at decreasing the pain, knee instability and the inability to exercise that occurs with ACL weakness or injury.
    • Athletes and non-athletes people with physically demanding work can continue to train or work during treatment there is typically no reason for immobilization.

    Return To Physical Activity

    A modified version of the Tegner Activity Scale was used to assess the level of PA pre-injury, at 18 months and at 35 years after the ACL reconstruction. The Tegner is graded from 1 to 10, with 1 representing the least strenuous knee activity and 10 representing the most strenuous knee activity, such as rugby and international football. The Tegner has been reported to have acceptable testretest reliability, with an ICC of 0.8 for patients with an ACL injury or reconstruction . The modified version does not contain the 0 score, which represents sick leave or disability pension because of knee problems in the original version. Furthermore, the modified version of the Tegner has recreational sports activities as a choice up to level 9.

    Don’t Miss: Types Of Wrist Surgery For Arthritis

    Arthritis Of The Joint

    Knee arthritis is a common problem, but most often associated with an elderly population. The most common type of arthritis is called osteoarthritis and is often referred to as wear-and-tear arthritis of the knee. When osteoarthritis occurs in the knee joint, the normally smooth, cushioning surface of the joint is worn away, leaving rough, exposed bone. The condition causes symptoms of pain, swelling, and deformity of the joint. Over time, the condition may worsen to a point that knee replacement may become an option.

    As mentioned, knee arthritis is typically a condition of aging. Most people with arthritis are in their 60s or older. There are some risk factors for developing arthritis that can make the condition occur earlier in life. One of those risk factors is trauma to the knee, and a common type of traumatic injury is a knee ligament injury. Orthopedic surgeons have long known that people who tear their knee ligaments, including the ACL, are more likely to develop arthritis, but knowing how commonly and how soon this might occur was unclear.

    Effect Of Surgical Techniques And Post

    Acute Knee Injury Rehabilitation – Ask Dr. Abelson

    Surgical techniques and post-operative rehabilitation programs are certainly a topic of ongoing debate and research studies. Importantly, regardless of surgical techniques and rehabilitation protocols, athletes returning to activity too early, prior to recovering baseline knee joint health and function, increase their risk for a subsequent ACL injury. The evidence in the literature indicates that significantly delaying a return to high level sports until nearly two years will benefit the athlete.

    Read Also: Weight Loss Surgery For Low Income

    Revision Acl Reconstruction Rehabilitation Protocol

    It is currently believed that biology needs to be respected more for revision ACL reconstructions than primary ACL reconstructions. Thus, the timeframe for advancement of activities is slower for revision ACL reconstruction to maximize the patients chance of success. In our practice, we have patients fully weightbearing after surgery, but they are on crutches a minimum of 4 weeks to ensure that they are unloading their ACL reconstruction graft initially. They wear an ACL brace through 6 months postoperatively to ensure that they do not have extra forces on their ACL when they twist, turn, or pivot. If they do not have any significant arthritis , or complex other injuries, such as meniscus root repairs, LCL reconstructions or MCL reconstructions, they may initiate a return to jogging program after the 4-month period and when they can perform a single-leg squat with no valgus collapse. Assessment of valgus collapse in the ACL reconstruction patients appears to be a very important way to ensure that patients have adequate strength before they start a jogging program. If they initiate a jogging program too soon, they may be damaging their cartilage because they may not have as good absorption and they also may be putting extra stress on their ACL reconstruction graft which could cause it to stretch out over time.

    The Younger Hamstring Graft Is Too Stiff Younger Patients Have Worse Surgical Outcomes

    A January 2022 study in the International Orthopaedics by researchers at the University of Auckland. In this study, they examined if a younger patients hamstring tendon was too stiff. Here are the learning points of their study:

    • The hamstring tendon is the most commonly used autograft material in reconstructive surgeries of anterior cruciate ligament tears. Younger patients have worse surgical outcomes, with a higher risk of re-rupture. hypothesized that age-related changes in hamstring tendon properties affect the tendons propensity to rupture when used as an autograft in ACL reconstructions.

    The researchers then compared hamstring tendon samples obtained from people aged 20 years or younger to samples obtained from older people.

    • The researchers found that tendon samples from the older group than the younger group, whereas the stress to failure was similar in the two groups.
    • The hamstring tendon from younger people has higher stiffness than tendon from older people, and the profile of gene expression in tendon varies with age. These differences may negatively affect the performance of the hamstring tendon in ACL reconstructions in younger people.

    Don’t Miss: Hip Dysplasia Dog Surgery Cost

    Acl Surgery Recovery Time

    The first question has a simple but imprecise answer: itdepends.

    If your surgery was successful with no complications and youplan to follow the rehabilitation recommendations of your orthopedic surgeon tothe letter, the best guess is no less than six months. For some, it can take upto two years to get back to 100%.

    What Causes Acl Reconstruction Failure

    Double Bundle ACL Reconstruction in Singapore

    ACL reconstruction failure can be caused by many factors. First, if an athlete returns to competition prior to having full endurance, proprioception, strength and agility, they are at risk for an ACL reconstruction failure even if the graft is perfectly placed. Thus, a proper rehabilitation program and passing a sports specific functional test like the Vail Sports Test would be indicated for high-level athletes.

    Similarly, going back to activities too soon after an allograft ACL reconstruction also puts one at risk for failure. This is because allografts can take up to 50% longer to heal compared to using ones own tissue. This is believed to be the main reason why allografts fail up to 45-50% of the time in patients that are less than 25 years of age. Other causes of ACL reconstruction failure include technical errors with placing the tunnels in the wrong positions, meniscus root or ramp tears, posterolateral corner injuries, MCL injuries, and an increase in posterior tibial slope.

    Read Also: How To Keep Dog From Scooting After Surgery

    Latest news
    Related news